ColourPop Eyeshadow Stick Review 2026: Worth Trying?

Are you tired of spending forever blending eyeshadow palettes? Do you want a quick and easy way to create stunning eye looks in minutes? ColourPop eyeshadow sticks might be exactly what you need. These cream eyeshadow sticks have taken the beauty world by storm in 2026, and for good reason. They offer rich pigmentation, smooth application, and all day wear in a convenient twist up pencil format.

This review covers everything you need to know about ColourPop Shadow Stix. You will discover which shades work best, how they perform throughout the day, and whether they are worth your money. We tested multiple shades to give you honest feedback. Whether you are a makeup beginner or a beauty enthusiast, this guide will help you decide if these eyeshadow sticks deserve a spot in your makeup bag.

Key Takeaways

Quick Overview of ColourPop Shadow Stix: These cream eyeshadow sticks deliver impressive color payoff in one swipe. They come with a built in sharpener for precise application.

Affordable Pricing: At just nine dollars per stick, these eyeshadow sticks offer high end quality at drugstore prices. You get professional results without breaking the bank.

Long Lasting Formula: The cream formula sets to a crease resistant finish that lasts up to 12 hours. No primer needed for most skin types, which saves you time and money.

Extensive Shade Range: ColourPop offers over 30 shades ranging from everyday neutrals to bold statement colors. You can find matte finishes, shimmery metallics, and gorgeous multichrome options.

Easy Application: The smooth texture glides on effortlessly. You can apply with the stick directly or blend with your fingers. Perfect for busy mornings when you need makeup that works fast.

What Are ColourPop Shadow Stix

ColourPop Shadow Stix are cream based eyeshadow sticks designed for quick and easy application. These twist up pencils eliminate the need for brushes or complicated blending techniques. You simply swipe the color directly onto your eyelids.

The formula features a creamy texture that glides smoothly across your skin. It sets within seconds to a long wearing finish that resists creasing and fading. Each stick measures 0.05 ounces and comes with a built in sharpener at the bottom. This design helps you maintain a precise tip for detailed application.

ColourPop launched these eyeshadow sticks as an updated version of their original Colour Stix line. The new formula offers better pigmentation and more consistent performance across all shades. The brand focuses on creating affordable makeup that delivers high quality results. These sticks embody that philosophy perfectly.

The packaging is simple yet functional. Each stick has a clear window that shows the exact shade inside. You can easily identify colors in your collection without testing them. The twist mechanism works smoothly without any jamming or breaking issues.

ColourPop Shadow Stix Honey BB

Honey BB stands out as one of the most popular shades in the ColourPop Shadow Stix lineup. This warm champagne gold delivers beautiful shimmer that catches the light perfectly. The shade works wonderfully as an all over lid color or as an inner corner highlight.

The formula applies smoothly without any tugging or patchiness. You get full color payoff in just one swipe. The shimmer particles are finely milled, which means they look sophisticated rather than glittery. This makes Honey BB appropriate for both daytime and evening looks.

This shade complements a wide range of skin tones. It looks especially stunning on warm and neutral undertones. The champagne gold brings brightness to your eyes without looking too bold or overwhelming. You can wear it alone for a quick polished look or layer it over other shades for added dimension.

The lasting power of Honey BB is impressive. It stays put for over 10 hours without creasing or fading. You do not need to worry about touch ups throughout the day. The color remains vibrant from morning until night, which makes it perfect for long workdays or special events.

ColourPop Shadow Stix Socialite

Socialite represents the ideal everyday neutral in the Shadow Stix collection. This soft taupe brown shade features a subtle shimmer that adds depth without being too dramatic. The color looks like your eyelids but better, creating a naturally enhanced appearance.

The texture of Socialite feels incredibly smooth and creamy. It blends effortlessly whether you use your fingers or a brush. The shade builds beautifully if you want more intensity. One layer gives you a soft wash of color, while multiple layers create a more defined look.

This shade has become a favorite among makeup artists and beauty enthusiasts. It works as a transition shade, an all over lid color, or a base for more colorful looks. The versatility makes Socialite worth owning even if you have a large eyeshadow collection.

Users report that Socialite lasts all day without any creasing issues. The formula sets quickly after application, which prevents it from smudging or transferring. This makes it an excellent choice for people with oily eyelids who struggle with regular eyeshadow formulas.

Texture and Formula Quality

The texture of ColourPop Shadow Stix deserves special attention. These eyeshadow sticks feature a creamy consistency that melts into your skin upon contact. The formula strikes the perfect balance between being soft enough to blend easily and firm enough to maintain its shape in the tube.

The sticks glide across your eyelids without any dragging or tugging. This smooth application makes them comfortable to use, even on delicate eye areas. You do not experience any irritation or discomfort during application. The formula feels lightweight on your skin rather than heavy or greasy.

ColourPop uses a cream to powder technology in these sticks. The product applies as a cream, which allows for easy blending and manipulation. Then it sets to a powder like finish within 30 to 60 seconds. This setting time gives you enough opportunity to blend and adjust before it locks in place.

The pigmentation quality varies slightly between different finish types. Metallic shades typically offer the most intense color payoff. Matte shades require an extra swipe or two for full opacity. However, all shades deliver good color intensity that looks professional and polished.

Top 3 Alternatives for ColourPop Eyeshadow Sticks

Shade Range and Color Selection

ColourPop offers an impressive variety of Shadow Stix shades that cater to different preferences and skin tones. The collection includes over 30 permanent shades plus limited edition releases throughout the year. You can find options in every color family imaginable.

The neutral category features warm champagnes, cool taupes, rich bronzes, and classic browns. These everyday shades work perfectly for creating natural eye looks that enhance your features. Shades like Honey BB, Cocktail Party, and Bare With Me remain consistently popular for daily wear.

Bold color lovers have plenty of options too. The range includes vibrant purples, stunning blues, emerald greens, and fiery oranges. These statement shades allow you to experiment with colorful makeup without committing to expensive palettes. Colors like Walk of Fame and Next Spot add instant drama to any look.

The finish options span matte, shimmer, and metallic categories. Matte shades provide a soft, velvety appearance perfect for subtle definition. Shimmer shades offer a gentle sparkle that catches light beautifully. Metallic shades deliver intense shine and reflective finishes for glamorous evening looks.

Application Tips and Techniques

Applying ColourPop Shadow Stix correctly makes a significant difference in the final result. Start with clean, dry eyelids for the best adherence. You do not need primer for these sticks, but using one can extend wear time even further.

For all over lid color, swipe the stick directly across your eyelid in gentle back and forth motions. Work quickly while the product remains creamy and blendable. Use your fingertip to smooth out any edges and blend the color seamlessly into your skin. The warmth from your finger helps the product meld with your skin tone.

Creating a cut crease or defined look requires more precision. Sharpen the stick to create a fine point. Use the pointed tip to draw your desired shape along the crease. Then blend the edges carefully while keeping the center area crisp and defined.

Layering different shades creates beautiful dimensional looks. Apply lighter shades first as your base. Then add darker shades in the outer corner or crease. Blend where the colors meet using your finger or a fluffy brush. The cream formula makes color blending intuitive and foolproof.

Longevity and Wear Time

The wear time of ColourPop Shadow Stix impresses most users. These eyeshadow sticks deliver solid performance that lasts throughout busy days. Once the cream formula sets, it stays put without significant fading or creasing.

On normal to dry eyelids, you can expect 10 to 12 hours of wear. The color remains vibrant and the finish stays intact without needing touch ups. The eyeshadow does not migrate into your crease or collect in fine lines. This makes these sticks reliable for long workdays or special events.

Oily eyelids may experience slightly reduced wear time. Some users report gentle fading after 8 to 10 hours. However, the eyeshadow still performs better than many traditional powder formulas. Using an eyeshadow primer can help extend wear time if you have particularly oily lids.

The eyeshadow resists smudging and transfer once it sets completely. You can rub your eyes lightly without completely removing the color. However, these sticks are not completely waterproof. Heavy sweating or water exposure will cause some fading. For activities like swimming or intense workouts, you may want a truly waterproof formula.

Best Shades for Different Skin Tones

Choosing the right shades enhances your natural features beautifully. ColourPop Shadow Stix work across all skin tones, but certain shades complement specific undertones especially well.

Fair skin tones look stunning in lighter shimmers and soft neutrals. Honey BB creates a beautiful bright effect without overwhelming pale skin. Cold Girl offers an icy white shimmer perfect for highlighting. Cocktail Party provides natural depth without appearing too dark.

Medium skin tones can wear almost any shade in the collection. Quokka delivers a gorgeous bronze that enhances warm undertones. Socialite creates perfect everyday definition. Walk of Fame adds beautiful purple dimension that flatters medium complexions.

Deep skin tones shine in rich, intensely pigmented shades. Next Spot offers a stunning copper that looks incredible against darker skin. So Into U provides beautiful dimension with its deep shimmer. Midnight Hour creates dramatic definition for bold eye looks.

Cool undertones benefit from shades with blue, purple, or silver bases. These colors complement the natural pink tones in cool skin. Warm undertones look best in golds, bronzes, and warm browns that enhance golden skin tones.

Comparing ColourPop to High End Brands

ColourPop Shadow Stix compete impressively with luxury eyeshadow sticks costing three to four times more. The formula quality rivals high end options from brands like Laura Mercier and Bobbi Brown. You get comparable performance at a fraction of the price.

Laura Mercier Caviar Sticks cost around 33 dollars per stick. They offer excellent longevity and smooth application. However, ColourPop Shadow Stix deliver similar results for just nine dollars. The main differences lie in packaging aesthetics rather than formula performance.

Bobbi Brown Long Wear Cream Shadow Sticks retail for 34 dollars. They provide beautiful color and impressive staying power. ColourPop matches this wear time while offering a wider shade range. The budget friendly price point makes experimenting with multiple colors affordable.

The texture of ColourPop sticks feels slightly softer than some luxury options. This makes them easier to blend but may require more careful handling to avoid breaking. The color payoff matches or exceeds many high end alternatives, especially in metallic finishes.

Matte vs Metallic Finish Options

ColourPop offers Shadow Stix in both matte and metallic finishes. Understanding the differences helps you choose the right options for your preferred looks.

Matte shades provide a soft, velvety finish without any shimmer or shine. These work beautifully for natural daytime looks. Matte options like Hey Boo and Midnight Hour create depth and definition without drawing excessive attention. They blend seamlessly and look sophisticated in professional settings.

The matte formula requires slightly more effort during application. You may need two to three swipes for full opacity. Building the color gradually prevents patchiness. The matte finish sets quickly, so work fast when blending edges.

Metallic shades deliver intense shine and reflective properties. These eyeshadow sticks create glamorous looks perfect for evenings and special occasions. Shades like Honey BB and So Into U catch light beautifully. The shimmer particles create dimension that makes your eyes appear larger.

Metallic shades apply more easily than matte options. The shimmer particles help the product glide smoothly across your eyelids. You typically get full color payoff in just one swipe. These shades work wonderfully as all over lid colors or as accent shades.

Common Issues and Solutions

While ColourPop Shadow Stix perform well overall, some users encounter specific challenges. Understanding these issues and their solutions helps you get the best results.

Problem: Creasing on oily eyelids. Some users with very oily lids experience creasing after several hours. Solution: Apply a thin layer of eyeshadow primer before using the stick. Set the cream eyeshadow with a matching powder eyeshadow to lock it in place.

Problem: Difficulty blending after the product sets. The quick setting time can make blending challenging if you work too slowly. Solution: Apply the eyeshadow to one eye at a time. Blend immediately after application while the formula remains creamy. Work in small sections rather than applying product to your entire lid at once.

Problem: Stick breaks or crumbles during application. This occasionally happens with softer formulas, especially in warm temperatures. Solution: Store your eyeshadow sticks in a cool, dry place. Avoid twisting up too much product. Apply gentle pressure during application rather than pressing hard.

Problem: Color appears patchy or uneven. This typically occurs with matte shades or on textured skin. Solution: Ensure your eyelids are clean and moisturized before application. Use a primer to create a smooth base. Build color gradually in thin layers.

Value for Money Analysis

ColourPop Shadow Stix offer exceptional value at nine dollars per stick. This price point makes them accessible to makeup lovers on any budget. You get high quality performance without the luxury price tag.

Comparing cost per ounce, ColourPop sticks contain 0.05 ounces of product. This translates to 180 dollars per ounce. While this seems high, eyeshadow sticks contain concentrated pigments. A little product goes a long way, making each stick last for months with regular use.

The longevity of each stick depends on usage frequency. Using a stick daily for all over lid color might deplete it within three to four months. Using it occasionally as an accent shade can make it last over a year. The built in sharpener helps you use every bit of product efficiently.

When you factor in the performance quality, ColourPop sticks provide incredible value. You eliminate the need for brushes, which saves money and simplifies your routine. The long wear time means you do not need to purchase setting sprays or primers for most applications.

Building Your Shadow Stix Collection

Starting your ColourPop Shadow Stix collection strategically ensures you get the most versatile options first. Begin with core neutral shades that work for everyday wear and various occasions.

Essential neutrals include Honey BB for a champagne highlight, Cocktail Party for all over lid color, and Quokka for bronze depth. These three shades create complete eye looks on their own or layer beautifully together. They complement all skin tones and work in professional settings.

Add one or two matte shades next. Midnight Hour provides classic black for definition and dramatic looks. Hey Boo offers a soft matte taupe perfect for subtle crease work. Matte shades help balance metallic finishes and create more complex looks.

Once you have neutrals covered, explore colorful options that match your style. Purple lovers should try Walk of Fame. Blue enthusiasts will love Next Spot. These statement shades allow creative expression while maintaining the easy application that makes Shadow Stix so convenient.

Best Combinations and Pairings

Creating beautiful eye looks becomes simple when you know which Shadow Stix shades work well together. These combinations deliver professional results with minimal effort.

Classic Neutral Look: Start with Cocktail Party across the entire lid. Add Quokka to the outer corner and blend into the crease. Highlight the inner corner with Honey BB. This combination creates a polished look appropriate for any occasion.

Bronze Goddess: Apply Quokka all over the lid. Deepen the outer corner with a matte brown shade. Add Cold Girl to the inner corner for a pop of brightness. This warm combination looks stunning on medium to deep skin tones.

Purple Statement: Use Socialite as your base shade across the lid. Apply Walk of Fame to the center of the lid for a bold purple pop. Blend the edges where the colors meet. Add Honey BB to the inner corner to brighten the look.

Simple Shimmer: Apply any metallic shade across your entire lid for a quick one and done look. Honey BB, So Into U, or Next Spot work beautifully on their own. This technique delivers maximum impact with minimum effort.

Removing ColourPop Shadow Stix

Removing these long lasting eyeshadow sticks requires the right approach. The cream formula sets firmly, which means regular makeup remover may not work efficiently.

Oil based makeup removers work best for dissolving Shadow Stix. Apply the remover to a cotton pad and hold it against your closed eyelid for 10 to 15 seconds. This allows the oil to break down the cream formula. Then gently wipe away the color without harsh rubbing.

Micellar water also removes these eyeshadows effectively. Choose a formula designed for waterproof makeup for best results. Saturate a cotton pad and press it against your eyelid. Swipe gently to remove the color completely.

Cleansing balms provide another excellent removal option. Massage the balm over your closed eyelids to dissolve the eyeshadow. The balm texture allows you to feel when the product has broken down. Rinse with warm water and follow with your regular cleanser.

Avoid tugging or rubbing harshly at your delicate eye area. These actions can damage the thin skin around your eyes and cause premature aging. Be patient and let your makeup remover do the work.

Sensitive Skin Considerations

People with sensitive skin often worry about cream eyeshadow formulas. ColourPop Shadow Stix generally perform well for most skin types, including sensitive skin. However, understanding the formula helps you make informed decisions.

The eyeshadow sticks are cruelty free and vegan friendly. ColourPop does not test on animals and formulates products without animal derived ingredients. This ethical approach appeals to conscious consumers who care about product sourcing.

The formula does not contain parabens or sulfates. These ingredients commonly cause irritation in sensitive skin. ColourPop focuses on creating formulas that minimize potential irritants while maintaining performance quality.

However, individual reactions vary based on specific sensitivities. Some users may react to certain pigments or preservatives in the formula. If you have known allergies or extremely sensitive skin, patch test the product before applying it near your eyes.

The cream formula sits on top of your skin rather than absorbing deeply. This reduces the chance of irritation compared to liquid formulas. If you experience any burning, itching, or redness, discontinue use immediately and consult with a dermatologist.

Professional Makeup Artist Opinions

Professional makeup artists have embraced ColourPop Shadow Stix for both personal and professional use. Their expert perspectives provide valuable insights into these products.

Many artists praise the convenience factor of these sticks. They simplify kit organization and speed up application time during busy shoots or events. The twist up format eliminates the need for carrying multiple brushes and palettes.

The blendability impresses professionals who work with various skin types. The cream formula adapts well to different skin textures and ages. Artists report that the sticks work beautifully on mature skin without settling into fine lines.

The color range receives high marks from professionals. Having access to both neutral and bold color options in one formula type makes creating diverse looks easier. Artists can achieve everything from natural bridal makeup to dramatic editorial looks.

Some professionals note that the sticks work better for certain applications than others. They excel at all over lid color and simple looks. More complex techniques requiring precise placement and blending may benefit from traditional powder formulas and brushes.

Storage and Shelf Life

Proper storage extends the life of your ColourPop Shadow Stix and maintains their performance quality. These cream products require specific care to prevent drying out or changing texture.

Store your eyeshadow sticks in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight. Heat can soften the cream formula excessively, making the sticks prone to breaking. Sunlight can degrade the pigments over time, affecting color accuracy.

Keep the caps tightly closed when not in use. Exposure to air can cause the cream formula to dry out and become difficult to apply. The twist mechanism should remain clean to prevent jamming. Wipe away any product buildup around the opening regularly.

ColourPop does not print expiration dates on individual Shadow Stix. However, cream eyeshadow products typically last 12 to 18 months after opening. Watch for changes in texture, smell, or performance as signs that the product has expired.

If your stick becomes too hard or dry, you may be able to revive it. Warm the tip gently by holding it near your skin for a few seconds. This can soften the formula enough for application. However, severely dried out products should be discarded.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do ColourPop eyeshadow sticks crease on oily eyelids?

ColourPop Shadow Stix perform well on most lid types. They set to a crease resistant finish within one minute of application. People with normal to dry eyelids typically experience no creasing throughout the day. Those with very oily lids may notice slight creasing after 8 to 10 hours. Using an eyeshadow primer before application significantly improves wear time on oily lids. The primer creates a barrier that prevents natural oils from breaking down the cream formula.

How long do ColourPop eyeshadow sticks last before drying out?

ColourPop Shadow Stix have a shelf life of approximately 12 to 18 months after opening. The cream formula can dry out if exposed to air frequently or stored in warm conditions. Keeping the cap tightly closed and storing sticks in cool places helps maintain the formula. Signs that your stick has expired include changes in texture, difficulty applying smoothly, or an unusual smell. Most users find their sticks remain usable for over a year with regular use.

Can you blend ColourPop Shadow Stix together?

Yes, you can blend multiple Shadow Stix shades together beautifully. The cream formula allows for seamless blending while the product remains wet. Apply your first shade and blend it out quickly. Then apply your second shade where you want the colors to meet. Use your fingertip or a fluffy brush to blend where the colors overlap. Work fast because the formula sets within 30 to 60 seconds. Once set, the colors become difficult to blend further without disturbing the base layer.

Do ColourPop eyeshadow sticks work as eyeliner?

ColourPop Shadow Stix can double as eyeliner for softer looks. The built in sharpener allows you to create a fine point perfect for lining. The cream formula glides along the lash line smoothly without tugging. However, these sticks do not create the sharp, precise lines that gel or liquid eyeliners provide. They work best for smudgy, smokey liner looks. The formula sets quickly, so you have limited time to smudge or blend the line after application.

Are ColourPop Shadow Stix worth buying in 2026?

ColourPop Shadow Stix offer excellent value and performance in 2026. They deliver high quality results at an affordable price point of nine dollars per stick. The formula compares favorably to luxury brands costing three times more. The convenience of cream stick application saves time during busy mornings. The color range provides options for every style and skin tone. If you want easy to use eyeshadow that lasts all day, these sticks are absolutely worth purchasing.

What is the best way to sharpen ColourPop eyeshadow sticks?

ColourPop Shadow Stix come with a built in sharpener attached to the bottom of each stick. Remove the cap from the bottom to access the sharpener. Insert the eyeshadow tip into the sharpener hole and twist gently. Remove the stick and check the point. Repeat if needed until you achieve your desired sharpness. The built in sharpener ensures you always have the right size for the product. You do not need to purchase separate sharpeners or worry about compatibility issues.